"Love Actually Is The Least Romantic Film of All Time" by Christopher Orr from The Atlantic
http://www.theatlantic.com/entertainment/archive/2013/12/-em-love-actually-em-is-the-least-romantic-film-of-all-time/282091/
Sam Smathers 4th
The main purpose is of this article is to refute the argument that "Love Actually", a popular british love story filmed a lot like "Valentines Day" with many small plots, is an accurate love story. The author says that love is presented to be all about physical attraction in this movie and that the movie presents love to be something that is easily obtained. The author says that the movie portrays the hardest part of love declaring out loud that you are in love, and that everything after the proclamation is easy. Some people claim that "Love Actually" is a holiday movie and the author says that in no way shape or form is this move a holiday movie, despite the fact it takes place over Christmas. Christopher Orr is bitter about how this movie makes Christmas into a sort of Valentines day and is salty about the way love is conveyed in this movie.
I recently watched "Love Actually" for the first time this weekend on one of the ice days. I actually really liked the movie and thought that for most of the individual plot lines it described how people react to real love accurately. For the sake of this being a movie, of course the characters manage to fall in love in a two week time span, but other than that I found nothing un realistic about the movie at all. The movie shows that love can conquer all obstacles such as language, age, and stereotypes. One of the plot lines is about a writer who falls in love with his portuguese house maid. He realizes his love for her when she jumps into the lake to save his book that had blown away in the wind, naturally she takes off her shirt and pants before jumping in. The Christopher Orr only recognized that the writer fell for the maid after she got semi naked, not the fact that she jumped in a freezing cold lake to save the manuscript. Orr also said that the only reason why the writer later learned Portuguese was to propose to her. Orr neglects to acknowledge that these two people spent a lot of time together, just them two in a cabin. The writer and the maid may not know each other in by language, but they know each other through their silence. Instead of emphasizing the physical or the verbal part of a relationship this plot serves to emphasize the silence of a relationship, and how love doesn't rely on words, love relays on how you feel around someone in silence. At the end of the movie the writer flies to Brazil, finds her, and proposes in Portuguese, if there is a greater gesture of love let me know because I don't think it is possible. This movie shows to highlight the exceptions to how people normally fall in love, it is all about the whole soul mate love is the most powerful stuff. People normally fall in love through spending a ton of time with someone and then they kinda just say that they are in love because the other person accepts their weird flaws and kills the spiders. This movie shows love without all of the elapsed time. The movie captures the first realization of love because it is most exciting beautiful thing on earth and this realization of love is what gives people hope, the fighting twenty years later gives no one hope, so this is not the focus.
I completely agree with you; love is extremely powerful. I think Orr missed the point in the case of the writer and the maid. The facet of the physical attraction in this relationship likely played a part, but the action of jumping into the lake was definitely more important in the realization of love.
ReplyDeleteByron Otis- Okay, how necessary is it to take off your shirt *and pants* when jumping into a lake? Like your clothes are going to be ruined even more than the book already is? It's definitely saying something, and goes far beyond the duties of a maid. Either she's determined to be known as "the crazy maid who jumps into lakes" or she's making a ploy to obtain this learned, obviously rich man's affection. Sure, love and all that. Okay, that's fine with me. But shirt *and* pants? Gosh.
ReplyDelete